My Redeemer Lives Considered From The Standpoint Of Grammar

WARNING: gram­mar geek­i­ness ahead.

I hate songs with non­sen­si­cal lyrics, espe­cial­ly those that pur­port to be wor­ship songs. The lyrics of a song mat­ter far more to me than their accom­pa­ny­ing music: I would for­bid a song from being played in my min­istry for hav­ing bad lyrics but nev­er for hav­ing chords which I did not like.

And so I was espe­cial­ly pleased to make sense of some puz­zling lyrics in My Redeemer Lives

kill switch divx down­load

in church this morn­ing.

The prob­lem­at­ic stan­za is

You lift my bur­dens
I’ll rise with You
I’m danc­ing on this moun­tain top
to see Your king­dom come

I was hung up on the word “to”, which I took to mean “I am danc­ing on this moun­tain top in order to bring about Your King­dom’s arrival.” In anoth­er lan­guage this would be called a dative of pur­pose. This trou­bled me, because as Lind­sey down­load the tragedy of mac­beth online down­load drag me to hell dvd down­load the name­sake online

said this morn­ing, “There are few things less like­ly to bring about the king­dom than danc­ing on a moun­tain. How about feed­ing some home­less peo­ple or talk­ing to some­one about Jesus?”

But then I real­ized there were at least two oth­er inter­pre­ta­tions of the word “to”. It could be like a dative of instru­ment (“I am danc­ing on this moun­tain top because I get a good view from up here which enables me to behold Your king­dom as it spreads on earth”) or like an abla­tive of atten­dant cir­cum­stances (“To see your King­dom come caus­es me to dance on this moun­tain top”).

I sus­pect it’s the lat­ter.

So now I can sing that song.

For the 1% of you who have been sim­i­lar­ly puz­zled, you’re wel­come.

For the 80% of you won­der­ing if I made up the words dative and abla­tive, check out Wikipedi­a’s list of gram­mat­i­cal cas­es.

3 thoughts on “My Redeemer Lives Considered From The Standpoint Of Grammar”

  1. glad to know I am not the only per­son who has banned songs on gram­mat­i­cal / non-sen­si­cal basis… it is amaz­ing what we allow because we only real­ly need to emote… not think in our wor­ship. I banned “my glo­ri­ous”… my glo­ri­ous what?

    1. Now I want to play madlibs.

      “My glo­ri­ous… car.”
      “My glo­ri­ous.… sun­glass­es.”
      “My glo­ri­ous… cook­ie.”

      Heh.

  2. Seri­ous­ly. One day I was like, “Huh? Wait a minute, what the heck are we singing about?” I agree with your final inter­pre­ta­tion. I know this is an old post, and I prob­a­bly should­n’t even care, but I do. Why on a moun­tain top? Because it’s close to God? Because every­one can see you? Or because it sounds nice? Oth­er? I don’t know, but just kick­ing around the idea…

Leave a Reply