I’m not shar­ing this because of the top­ic or the author’s point of view. Instead, he made a fas­ci­nat­ing obser­va­tion: “How much free speech do we have? It depends on the medi­um. Maybe the sequence from less to more cen­sored is: 1. Con­ver­sa­tion. 2. Email and oth­er pri­vate writ­ing. 3. Blog post. 4. Poor­ly-writ­ten book. 5. Arti­cle in minor mag­a­zine. 6. Well-writ­ten book. 7. Arti­cle in pres­ti­gious mag­a­zine. 8. Text­book. From one step to the next (e.g., from con­ver­sa­tion to email), views become less diverse.” I am not sure I buy the mid­dle points of his con­tin­u­um (although maybe he means by “well-writ­ten book” some­thing more like “con­tro­ver­sial book writ­ten by some­one oth­er­wise cul­tur­al­ly respectable”).

Seth’s Blog » Blog Archive » “The Most Influ­en­tial Tree in the World”

When the fig­ures were pub­lished the extra­or­di­nary lack of data under­ly­ing the blade of the Yamal hock­ey stick caused a minor sen­sa­tion. In fact the high point at the end of the graph was shown to have…

Leave a Reply