Things Glen Found Interesting, Volume 506: isms, nonsense responders, and tap water

On Fri­days I share articles/resources about broad cul­tur­al, soci­etal and the­o­log­i­cal issues. Be sure to see the expla­na­tion and dis­claimers at the bot­tom. I wel­come your sug­ges­tions. If you read some­thing fas­ci­nat­ing please pass it my way.

Things Glen Found Interesting

  1. ismism (J. Budziszews­ki, blog): “Ismism – four syl­la­bles, ‘izzum izzum’ — is the bad men­tal habit of crit­i­ciz­ing a propo­si­tion not on its own terms, but in terms of the ‘ism’ which one takes it to express. For exam­ple, sup­pose Sheila is con­cerned that young peo­ple who mar­ry are tying the knot lat­er and lat­er in life. Bri­an snorts, ‘You’re one of those con­ju­gal­ists.’ Then he crit­i­cizes Sheila for oth­er beliefs which he him­self asso­ciates with so-called con­ju­gal­ism. For instance, he protests ‘I don’t think every­one has to mar­ry.’ But Sheila didn’t say that every­one has to mar­ry. She may not even think so, and it doesn’t fol­low as a con­clu­sion from her premise. Ismism is guilt by asso­ci­a­tion: ‘Your belief must be wrong, because I, per­son­al­ly, group it with oth­er beliefs I con­sid­er wrong.’ ”
    • The author is a phi­los­o­phy prof at UT Austin.
  2. Fas­ci­nat­ing: “non­sense respon­ders” sig­nif­i­cant­ly affect sur­vey data https://x.com/cremieuxrecueil/status/1926128833947738321
    • The entire thread is worth read­ing. Bot­tom line from a tweet near the end of the thread: “Men­tal­ly adjust sur­vey results in your head if you don’t see the authors rig­or­ous­ly work­ing to remove non­sense respon­ders.”
  3. How to Find Ancient Assyr­i­an Cities Using Eco­nom­ics (Max Tabar­rok, Sub­stack): “In ancient Kaneš, court tran­scripts, trad­ing con­tracts, and mer­chant account­ing were all record­ed on clay tablets. Clay tablets pre­serve well, so this peri­od is in some ways bet­ter known then the next sev­er­al thou­sand years of his­to­ry. The authors claim that ‘the clos­est com­pa­ra­ble cor­po­ra of ancient trade data are almost 3,000 years lat­er, com­ing, for exam­ple, from the medieval Ital­ian mer­chant archives and the Cairo Genizah’.… The cher­ry on top: the entire city burned in a fire, pre­serv­ing the clay records to be recov­ered forty cen­turies lat­er. The authors use some nat­ur­al lan­guage pro­cess­ing and man­u­al inspec­tion to nar­row down from tens of thou­sands of tablets to sev­er­al hun­dred unam­bigu­ous men­tions of trade between two of 25 Ana­to­lian cities that have enough trade con­nec­tions with each oth­er to be iden­ti­fied in a grav­i­ty mod­el.”
  4. Star Har­vard busi­ness pro­fes­sor stripped of tenure, fired for manip­u­lat­ing data in stud­ies on dis­hon­esty (Richard Pol­li­na, New York Post): “A renowned Har­vard Uni­ver­si­ty pro­fes­sor was stripped of her tenure and fired after an inves­ti­ga­tion found she fab­ri­cat­ed data on mul­ti­ple stud­ies focused on dis­hon­esty.”
    • Rec­om­mend­ed by a stu­dent.
  5. Doug Wil­son Has Spent Decades Push­ing for a Chris­t­ian Theoc­ra­cy. In Trump’s DC, the New Right Is Lis­ten­ing. (Ian Ward, Politi­co): “In Moscow, Wil­son explained that his polit­i­cal phi­los­o­phy is not theo­crat­ic in the com­mon­ly under­stood sense of a gov­ern­ment run exclu­sive­ly by the church. To the con­trary, he main­tains that God ordains earth­ly author­i­ty in three sep­a­rate spheres of life: the church, the fam­i­ly and the civ­il gov­ern­ment. With­in each of these spheres, the rel­e­vant author­i­ties must abide by scrip­tur­al com­mand­ments. In the famil­ial sphere, for instance, par­ents must edu­cate their chil­dren accord­ing to Bib­li­cal prin­ci­ples, and wives must sub­or­di­nate them­selves to their hus­bands in accor­dance with a covenan­tal view of the fam­i­ly. In the sphere of civ­il gov­ern­ment, offi­cials should strive to bring the law in line with Bib­li­cal com­mand­ments, although those prin­ci­ples don’t have to be applied ‘wood­en­ly,’ as Wil­son put it: Gov­ern­ments do not have to enforce the Bib­li­cal man­date that house­holds build balustrades on their roofs, but they should enforce the prin­ci­ple that home­own­ers are liable for risks incurred on their prop­er­ty. Above all, Wil­son believes, the three spheres of earth­ly author­i­ty must remain sep­a­rate.”
    • This is a far more informed arti­cle than I expect­ed it to be. The jour­nal­ist (Ian Ward) and the sub­ject (Doug Wil­son) have both been fea­tured in these emails before. I high­ly rec­om­mend this arti­cle as an exam­ple of what fair report­ing of a reli­gious per­son looks like.
    • For a taste of Wilson’s style, check out his response to this and a few oth­er arti­cles about him: Pete Hegseth, Me, and Meet­ing with Impor­tant Jews (Doug Wil­son, per­son­al blog).
    • My quick take on Wil­son: when he is right he is very right and when he is wrong he is very wrong, and whether he is right or wrong he is almost always con­fi­dent and enter­tain­ing.
  6. The Unpar­al­leled Dai­ly Mir­a­cle of Tap Water (A. Cerisse Cohen, New York Times): “Dur­ing a two-year stint in Mon­tana, I went on long hikes and sipped stream water, shock­ing­ly cold and straight from the glac­i­ers, but oth­er than that, I drank from the tap. And then I land­ed in Los Ange­les, where every­one I met used a fil­ter.… Thanks to warn­ings from seem­ing­ly every­one around me in the city, I began to wor­ry about things I nev­er before con­sid­ered threat­en­ing, like dust (could cause can­cer), any­thing with seeds (could cause can­cer) or cer­tain plan­e­tary con­fig­u­ra­tions (respon­si­ble for all oth­er mis­for­tunes). If I put my purse on the floor, or ori­ent­ed my bed the wrong way, it was endan­ger­ing my ener­gy! Maybe I’d been lulled into a false sense of secu­ri­ty about every­day life.”
    • Drink tap water. It’s awe­some.
  7. U.S. Will ‘Aggres­sive­ly’ Revoke Visas of Chi­nese Stu­dents, Rubio Says (Edward Wong, New York Times): “Sec­re­tary of State Mar­co Rubio announced on Wednes­day evening that the Trump admin­is­tra­tion would work to ‘aggres­sive­ly revoke’ visas of Chi­nese stu­dents, includ­ing those with ties to the Chi­nese Com­mu­nist Par­ty or who are study­ing in ‘crit­i­cal fields.’.… In 2020, offi­cials in the first Trump admin­is­tra­tion can­celed the visas of more than 1,000 Chi­nese grad­u­ate stu­dents and researchers after announc­ing they were ban­ning from cam­pus­es Chi­nese cit­i­zens with direct ties to mil­i­tary uni­ver­si­ties in their coun­try. It was the first time the U.S. gov­ern­ment had moved to bar a cat­e­go­ry of Chi­nese stu­dents from get­ting access to Amer­i­can uni­ver­si­ties, a ban the Biden admin­is­tra­tion kept in place.”

Less Serious Things Which Also Interested/Amused Glen

Why Do You Send This Email?

In the time of King David, the tribe of Issachar pro­duced shrewd war­riors “who under­stood the times and knew what Israel should do” (1 Chron 12:32). In a sim­i­lar way, we need to become wise peo­ple whose faith inter­acts with the world. I pray this email gives you greater insight, so that you may con­tin­ue the tra­di­tion of Issachar.

Disclaimer

Chi Alpha is not a par­ti­san orga­ni­za­tion. To para­phrase anoth­er min­is­ter: we are not about the donkey’s agen­da and we are not about the elephant’s agen­da — we are about the Lamb’s agen­da. Hav­ing said that, I read wide­ly (in part because I believe we should aspire to pass the ide­o­log­i­cal Tur­ing test and in part because I do not believe I can fair­ly say “I agree” or “I dis­agree” until I can say “I under­stand”) and may at times share arti­cles that have a strong par­ti­san bias sim­ply because I find the arti­cle stim­u­lat­ing. The upshot: you should not assume I agree with every­thing an author says in an arti­cle I men­tion, much less things the author has said in oth­er arti­cles (although if I strong­ly dis­agree with some­thing in the arti­cle I’ll usu­al­ly men­tion it). And to the extent you can dis­cern my opin­ions, please under­stand that they are my own and not nec­es­sar­i­ly those of Chi Alpha or any oth­er orga­ni­za­tion I may be per­ceived to rep­re­sent. Also, remem­ber that I’m not report­ing news — I’m giv­ing you a selec­tion of things I found inter­est­ing. There’s a lot hap­pen­ing in the world that’s not mak­ing an appear­ance here because I haven’t found stim­u­lat­ing arti­cles writ­ten about it. If this was for­ward­ed to you and you want to receive future emails, sign up here. You can also view the archives.

Leave a Reply